2009 Carrera S vs 2007 Turbo
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 480
From: OC, CA
Rep Power: 0
Thank you for your thoughts. I think the people who vote 09S are in the minority, but I'm fine with that.
There is a lot to be said about being fortunate enough to have a car built to satisfy your personal likes, wants, or needs. I am trading my 07S, which I ordered with everything I wanted, for a 09S with an Oct. build and Nov. delivery. I thoroughly enjoy my 07S because it is everything I wanted (color and interior) and not items that I can not use or even want on my car. This time I wanted Speed Yellow (not Grey, Silver, or Black), Standard leather (not Full), Sport shifter, PCCB brakes, Interior trim, etc., etc. I did not want Nav. (I like my Garmin Nuvi), no PDK, no iPod (next persons problem) or other items that a dealer might spec to help it move off his showroom floor. So, it obviously is very personal. I could be happy with any Pcar. But, for me the good fortune of having a car built to suit my needs and desires is more important than horsepower and torque numbers. My current 07S has more potential than I can use on public roads. If I am lucky enough to have future build it will be very different, but it will fulfill my needs at that time.
Good luck with your choice. You win either way. Also, you may want to read the cover story in the new (Oct.) Excellence magazine.
-Jay
Good luck with your choice. You win either way. Also, you may want to read the cover story in the new (Oct.) Excellence magazine.
-Jay
Banned
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 3,103
From: Kirkland, WA
Rep Power: 147
-modding voids factory warranty
-turbo is laggy, it's heavier, it's awd
-if the question was 09 Carrera S or 997 GT3, i'd pick the GT3.
-none of you have driven the new 3.8 yet
i don't understand the turbo envy.
-turbo is laggy, it's heavier, it's awd
-if the question was 09 Carrera S or 997 GT3, i'd pick the GT3.
-none of you have driven the new 3.8 yet
i don't understand the turbo envy.
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 9,108
From: South Florida
Rep Power: 529
Lastly --there's no guarantee that even Porsche will make a stock repair easy . I can point to posts of cars which were 100 percent stock and the owners were not happy with how the repais were handled.
In short --how a person gets his car fixed hinges on how well he can negotiate . .
As for "Tubo envy" --I feel all of these cars are greatly respected .
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 9,108
From: South Florida
Rep Power: 529
I can line up all my reasons . I stand behind each of them . But the very basic answer is as follows:
If I want to drive 20MPH next to a 997S --I can
If I want to drive 60 MPH next to a 997S --I can
If we take both cars and run them 0-150 --He can't keep up. With 700 Hp --the gap widens .
Just knowing that --even if its of no street value --was enough to choose the Turbo.
Last edited by yrralis1; Aug 14, 2008 at 02:56 PM.
Registered User
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 343
From: Seattle, WA
Rep Power: 53
Mary Ann or Ginger?
seems like a GT3 should be a consideration.
I like my 997S. i thought about a turbo. for the same money & options, i'd go with the turbo, but that's never the case.
i also like the PDK a lot....which i know is controversial.
brendo
seems like a GT3 should be a consideration.
I like my 997S. i thought about a turbo. for the same money & options, i'd go with the turbo, but that's never the case.
i also like the PDK a lot....which i know is controversial.
brendo
Registered User
Joined: Nov 2005
Posts: 1,550
From: Vancouver, BC, Canada
Rep Power: 116
I'll pick the 09 997S in your case, being well aware that the turbo is the faster car.
I know that cars are toys and are not considered an investment, but the depreciation of the 996TT is scary. If history is going to repeat itself, you can always pick up a 997TT for half price in 4-5 years time. Knowing that the GT1 engine block is so reliable, it will be a bargain at that time.
I can easily afford a 997TT, but my club coupe is so rare (only 50 made) that I have no intention to upgrade. There will always be faster cars than mine anyway.
Adding a GT3 to the stable will be another story...
I know that cars are toys and are not considered an investment, but the depreciation of the 996TT is scary. If history is going to repeat itself, you can always pick up a 997TT for half price in 4-5 years time. Knowing that the GT1 engine block is so reliable, it will be a bargain at that time.
I can easily afford a 997TT, but my club coupe is so rare (only 50 made) that I have no intention to upgrade. There will always be faster cars than mine anyway.
Adding a GT3 to the stable will be another story...
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 9,108
From: South Florida
Rep Power: 529
[QUOTE][the depreciation of the 996TT is scary/QUOTE]
A used 997 Turbo has some depreciation priced in . A new 09 997S does not and discounts on that car are iffy at best.
I do agree that he ought to get the car that he wants and if it happens to be a 997S then that's what it ought to be .
A used 997 Turbo has some depreciation priced in . A new 09 997S does not and discounts on that car are iffy at best.
I do agree that he ought to get the car that he wants and if it happens to be a 997S then that's what it ought to be .
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 480
From: OC, CA
Rep Power: 0
A gt3 was a consideration and honestly I prefer that car over the turbo. Keep in mind, I admit I'm a complete amateur in the Porsche world, but that is my "feeling." I've never been a fan of turbos, regardless of how incredibly fast they are. Something about an 8400 redline will always excite me and I'll sacrifice horsepower for that.
For my reasons stated and the fact that a used turbo is about 20k more than my optioned 09S (which I probably could afford, but it's definitely more than I would like to spend), I'm probably sticking with a 09S. For all you turbo owners, please drive slow so I can look at the side of your car and not just the tail lights.
For my reasons stated and the fact that a used turbo is about 20k more than my optioned 09S (which I probably could afford, but it's definitely more than I would like to spend), I'm probably sticking with a 09S. For all you turbo owners, please drive slow so I can look at the side of your car and not just the tail lights.
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 480
From: OC, CA
Rep Power: 0
That's not only inaccurate, but presumptious. Please enlighten us how you came to that "simple" conclusion.
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 9,108
From: South Florida
Rep Power: 529
http://www.supercars.net/PitLane?vie...ID=0&tID=10073
7.40 = Turbo at the ring
7.50 - 09 997S at the Ring (PDK)
7.59 = Current 997S at the ring
Different drivers of course --many variables-- but a win is a win!!!
7.40 = Turbo at the ring
7.50 - 09 997S at the Ring (PDK)
7.59 = Current 997S at the ring
Different drivers of course --many variables-- but a win is a win!!!
Last edited by yrralis1; Aug 14, 2008 at 09:18 PM.
