Hey All need some advice....Going car shopping today..A few months ago are 2009 Audi S6 got stolen....We just got a check from the insurance company yesterday so we're going car shopping today...If you had to choose between the following cars which would you go with and why....I'm sure I can knock 3-4k off of each car...After I wrap this ordeal up I'll be dumping the 997 S for a used GT3 or R8....Your help would be appreciated...FYI my wife is notorious for curb rash and mysterious dents that seem to appear from thin air...

2011 Black S4 Prestige 18k miles asking price 42k

2010 Black Audi S6 Prestige 28k miles asking price 46k