Aston Martin Vendor Classifieds vendor classified area...do not post here unless you are a forum sponsor

Supercharger or Turbo?

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Rate Thread
 
  #106  
Old 03-14-2017, 12:32 PM
Stuart@VelocityAP's Avatar
Basic Sponsor
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: Canada
Posts: 1,628
Rep Power: 117
Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by skywagon
Stuart,

I am looking forward to seeing how it runs. My main concern will be engine bay temperatures. Living in the Phoenix area I would still like to occasionally drive my car in the summer months. Do you have plans to instrument the engine bay to monitor those temps while running? I am more than willing to dial back boost for summer months but I am still concerned about the exhaust path routing and ambient temps.

I can see that with all the individual fabricated components that this is no easy undertaking for a production run. The initial jig set-up alone for the plumbing weldments is a significant task of it's own.

Impressive work so far.
We haven't installed any additional sensors other than allowing for a wideband O2 so we can monitor AFR on the road as well as the dyno.

We will be doing a fair bit of datalogging so we'll be able to monitor things like intake air temperature, which is a pretty good gauge of what's going on under the hood. One thing we have introduced, both due to proximity to the turbos but also as a heat exit is to vent the portion of the fender liner in front of the stanchion. We're also considering venting the rear portion out through the side strakes like on the DB11.

Everyone thinks in terms of WOT dyno runs, which do produce a lot of heat for certain, but some of the things we want to do are to go drive it and then let it sit there idling for 20 minutes and see what happens when there is no airflow. Real world stuff.

The ceramic and titanium wrap will do a pretty good job, as will the turbo blankets but some of this stuff we will just have to see how it pans out.
 
__________________
Stuart Dickinson
Managing Director
Velocity Automotive Performance Limited
206 Maple Avenue
Oliver, BC
Canada V2A 4W6
Office: (1)250-485-5126
www.velocityap.com
  #107  
Old 03-14-2017, 02:33 PM
skywagon's Avatar
Registered User
Join Date: Aug 2015
Location: Chandler, AZ
Posts: 135
Rep Power: 16
skywagon is a jewel in the roughskywagon is a jewel in the roughskywagon is a jewel in the rough
Originally Posted by Stuart@VelocityAP
We haven't installed any additional sensors other than allowing for a wideband O2 so we can monitor AFR on the road as well as the dyno.

We will be doing a fair bit of datalogging so we'll be able to monitor things like intake air temperature, which is a pretty good gauge of what's going on under the hood. One thing we have introduced, both due to proximity to the turbos but also as a heat exit is to vent the portion of the fender liner in front of the stanchion. We're also considering venting the rear portion out through the side strakes like on the DB11.

Everyone thinks in terms of WOT dyno runs, which do produce a lot of heat for certain, but some of the things we want to do are to go drive it and then let it sit there idling for 20 minutes and see what happens when there is no airflow. Real world stuff.

The ceramic and titanium wrap will do a pretty good job, as will the turbo blankets but some of this stuff we will just have to see how it pans out.
Stuart,

You are thinking just as I am; real world usability of a twin turbo Vantage. Mine is not a daily driver but I also want to know it will not overheat if I get stuck in traffic in a 100 degree day with the A/C going.

I look forward to hearing what you learn.
 
  #108  
Old 03-14-2017, 03:05 PM
deckman's Avatar
Registered User
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: MD
Posts: 2,689
Rep Power: 171
deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !
Have you added fans into your setup? It the bay gets too hot and the only solution is the V12 hood or something like that, it will be a price killer. The NA V8V engine bay is already the hottest of any car I've ever owned.

Are the turbos water or oil cooled? I assume there are intercoolers as well? (edit: I saw in post 28 you mentioned an intercooler. Is that one for each TC?)
 

Last edited by deckman; 03-14-2017 at 03:58 PM.
  #109  
Old 03-14-2017, 03:57 PM
Stuart@VelocityAP's Avatar
Basic Sponsor
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: Canada
Posts: 1,628
Rep Power: 117
Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by deckman
Have you added fans into your setup? It the bay gets too hot and the only solution is the V12 hood or something like that, it will be a price killer. The NA V8V engine bay is already the hottest of any car I've ever owned.

Are the turbos water or oil cooled? I assume there are intercoolers as well?
No fans. There's really not any more room to add that in, but as I said we have vented the fender liners. Our setup deletes the front 'snorkel' siamesed intake and airboxes, running a cone filter off the original MAF tube & location.

There is a 22x9x3.25" Intercooler mounted in front of the radiator, where the snorkel used to be. It is rated at 550WHP at 1.5psi of pressure drop across the core. We are currently running a 7psi wastegate, expect a 1psi drop across the core at around 430-440WHP, low 500's at the crank.

That is about the safe limit of the pistons, any more pressure, particularly if intake air temperatures aren't controlled with the intercooler and you risk cracking the ring lands. That's one of the reasons we opted for a larger core than we needed to support the boost levels.

The turbos are twin oil cooled Garrett GTX 2867R's.
 
__________________
Stuart Dickinson
Managing Director
Velocity Automotive Performance Limited
206 Maple Avenue
Oliver, BC
Canada V2A 4W6
Office: (1)250-485-5126
www.velocityap.com
  #110  
Old 03-14-2017, 09:53 PM
pikajew's Avatar
Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: beverly hills
Posts: 285
Rep Power: 29
pikajew is on a distinguished road
Originally Posted by Stuart@VelocityAP
No fans. There's really not any more room to add that in, but as I said we have vented the fender liners. Our setup deletes the front 'snorkel' siamesed intake and airboxes, running a cone filter off the original MAF tube & location.

There is a 22x9x3.25" Intercooler mounted in front of the radiator, where the snorkel used to be. It is rated at 550WHP at 1.5psi of pressure drop across the core. We are currently running a 7psi wastegate, expect a 1psi drop across the core at around 430-440WHP, low 500's at the crank.

That is about the safe limit of the pistons, any more pressure, particularly if intake air temperatures aren't controlled with the intercooler and you risk cracking the ring lands. That's one of the reasons we opted for a larger core than we needed to support the boost levels.

The turbos are twin oil cooled Garrett GTX 2867R's.
Badass.
 
  #111  
Old 03-15-2017, 08:09 AM
Zettinger's Avatar
Registered User
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: Fl
Posts: 687
Rep Power: 43
Zettinger is a glorious beacon of lightZettinger is a glorious beacon of lightZettinger is a glorious beacon of lightZettinger is a glorious beacon of lightZettinger is a glorious beacon of light
I'm excited about this outcome.

However I'm wondering about the sense of a TT Vantage V8 setup with a power goal below the already existing GMR 600 supercharger.

With that power goal, you have benfits of a S/C setup.
- Supercharger does not have a turbo lag
- Supercharger keep the linear power curve of an N/A engine with power delivery in high revs.
- Setup (in GMR case) seems to be plug and play of the intake. No mayor engine bay modifications required.
- good for up to 600Hp (crank) reliable out of a 4.3l (over 100k mile GMR Vantages on the street)
 
  #112  
Old 03-15-2017, 09:42 AM
Redpants's Avatar
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2016
Location: Tampa, FL
Age: 40
Posts: 4,995
Rep Power: 356
Redpants Is a GOD !Redpants Is a GOD !Redpants Is a GOD !Redpants Is a GOD !Redpants Is a GOD !Redpants Is a GOD !Redpants Is a GOD !Redpants Is a GOD !Redpants Is a GOD !Redpants Is a GOD !Redpants Is a GOD !
The problem with the GMR supercharger is that you can't get one unless you pay for them to come to you, or you send your car to them.
 
  #113  
Old 03-15-2017, 11:00 AM
deckman's Avatar
Registered User
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: MD
Posts: 2,689
Rep Power: 171
deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !
Besides, that ship has left. They could get 600hp out of this setup if they wnated. This is just a 120hp jumpt with two units in play. The problem I assume is that this is already a fairly high compression engine and so they are playing it as safe as possible with boost. Adding FI to a NA designed engine is always risky.

Full disclosure: I'm talking out of my rear end.
 

Last edited by deckman; 03-15-2017 at 11:14 AM.
  #114  
Old 03-15-2017, 01:07 PM
Zettinger's Avatar
Registered User
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: Fl
Posts: 687
Rep Power: 43
Zettinger is a glorious beacon of lightZettinger is a glorious beacon of lightZettinger is a glorious beacon of lightZettinger is a glorious beacon of lightZettinger is a glorious beacon of light
Originally Posted by Redpants
The problem with the GMR supercharger is that you can't get one unless you pay for them to come to you, or you send your car to them.
I had no idea.. Thanks for the info.

Does anyone has experience with the "ESX super Vantage" SC setup?













 

Last edited by Zettinger; 03-15-2017 at 01:16 PM.
  #115  
Old 03-15-2017, 02:00 PM
deckman's Avatar
Registered User
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: MD
Posts: 2,689
Rep Power: 171
deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !
It's hard for me to read those price for some reason, so tell me if this is a mistake. $28k for the supercharger set up? Is that right?
 
  #116  
Old 03-15-2017, 05:29 PM
rmrmd1956's Avatar
Registered User
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: 3rd Planet
Posts: 770
Rep Power: 56
rmrmd1956 is a glorious beacon of lightrmrmd1956 is a glorious beacon of lightrmrmd1956 is a glorious beacon of lightrmrmd1956 is a glorious beacon of lightrmrmd1956 is a glorious beacon of lightrmrmd1956 is a glorious beacon of light
Originally Posted by deckman
It's hard for me to read those price for some reason, so tell me if this is a mistake. $28k for the supercharger set up? Is that right?
bigger intake and exhaust valves with stronger springs
fully ported heads
custom stronger rods
thicker custom sleeves
custom CP pistons
You need all this in addition plus a lot more if you want reliable power above 600 in the Vantage
 
  #117  
Old 03-15-2017, 05:54 PM
deckman's Avatar
Registered User
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: MD
Posts: 2,689
Rep Power: 171
deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !deckman Is a GOD !
Yeah but the $28k for the supercharger was with stock internals, right? The engine upgrades are for withstanding up to 1,000 hp. At least that is what I thought I read in the tiny print.
 

Last edited by deckman; 03-15-2017 at 05:59 PM.
  #118  
Old 03-15-2017, 05:57 PM
rmrmd1956's Avatar
Registered User
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: 3rd Planet
Posts: 770
Rep Power: 56
rmrmd1956 is a glorious beacon of lightrmrmd1956 is a glorious beacon of lightrmrmd1956 is a glorious beacon of lightrmrmd1956 is a glorious beacon of lightrmrmd1956 is a glorious beacon of lightrmrmd1956 is a glorious beacon of light
Originally Posted by deckman
Yeah but the $28k for the supercharger was with stock internals, right?

Yes stock internals, thats the kit I started with.
No longer available
 
  #119  
Old 03-15-2017, 06:33 PM
Lve2xlr8's Avatar
Registered User
Join Date: May 2015
Location: Los Angeles
Posts: 75
Rep Power: 12
Lve2xlr8 is on a distinguished road
Would love to see a quality and reasonably priced positive displacement supercharger for the V8 Vantage. With all the forged components, it seems like this engine would be a good candidate. Harrop makes one of the cleanest aftermarket kits I've seen for the e9x v8 m3. Even utilizes the factory airbox. Keep in mind that the m3 has a 12 CR compared to the Vantage's 11.3 (10.5 for the 4.3). Other versions of the AJ-V8 work quite well under forced induction.


 
  #120  
Old 03-16-2017, 10:09 AM
Stuart@VelocityAP's Avatar
Basic Sponsor
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: Canada
Posts: 1,628
Rep Power: 117
Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !Stuart@VelocityAP Is a GOD !
My opinion, which is largely based on having seen multiple internal engine part failures on forced induction Vantages that I have not been involved with (I'm not referring to anything/anyone in particular some of these have never seen the light of day), is that the safe limit for these engines on forced induction is around 6PSI boost, which should get you over the 500BHP mark but not much further. IAT management is critical, for one. The GMR kit I think looks very good. I learned much about it going back to 2009 when they were first developing it, and they were definitely not cutting corners. 600BHP is more than I would feel comfortable with on stock internals, but then they appear to have a few cars out there with some pretty high mileages.

We're also getting into a very grey area in terms of what constitutes 'safe'. 3PSI and another 60BHP is less 'safe' than stock. So it isn't really a binary ok/not ok situation. The turbos we selected for our kit are capable of supporting 480BHP per turbo, according to Garrett. The core we have fitted is rated at 550WHP, say 700BHP at the crank. We have enough injector to get there with the upgraded ones we are using. That doesn't mean it's a good idea to just turn the boost up and let 'er rip.

However, 1000HP on stock internals? Hang on while I get my phone out.
 
__________________
Stuart Dickinson
Managing Director
Velocity Automotive Performance Limited
206 Maple Avenue
Oliver, BC
Canada V2A 4W6
Office: (1)250-485-5126
www.velocityap.com


You have already rated this thread Rating: Thread Rating: 0 votes,  average.

Quick Reply: Supercharger or Turbo?



All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:29 PM.