Price check for 2011 and 2012 base 2.9 Boxster
 

Currently debating between these 2 cars, both come with 6 speed manual transmission and 17 inch wheels:

1) 2011 Boxster 2.9, 18k miles, navigation, xenons, bose, warranty expires early 2015.

town-motorcar.porschedealer.com/used/Porsche/Boxster+Base/2011/Guards+Red/1098420/info.php

Dealer says its best price is 35k.

2) 2012 Boxster 2.9, 25k miles, xenons, bose, warranty expires early 2016.

avonautobrokers.com/2012-Porsche-Boxster/Used-Convertible/Avon-MA/4669334/Details.aspx

Dealer says its best price is 37k.


I like the lower miles and navi on the red one but like the colour and extra year of warranty on the white one.

How much do these go for at auction? Is the asking price fair?

Both these cars are very similar. The white one has power seats which is very nice. Wish my Boxster did. $2K is worth the extra value which goes with the '12 vs. '11, and extra warranty. But no nav and not everyone likes white. I bet you can find lower mile cars for less money if you look hard enough. I assume a warranty matters a lot to you?

I just bought a certified pre-owned, one owner 2011 base boxster for 33k. It had more miles than the two you are looking at. But I have a warranty until March 2017. No Bose or Nav though but it does have xenons, 18" wheels, heated seats and the rest.