My head is spinning.. light weight or dual mass??
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 874
From: Hawaii
Rep Power: 72
After spending a bunch of time with my newly LWFW car, I can finally understand the issue.
The noise is ALWAYS there. Whether or not a LWFW is for you likely depends on how loud it actually is, how rhythmic the sound is (relative to orher noises, di tou gave an exhaust?) and most importantly - whether you LIKE the resultant sound.
I find it easy to characterize mine as adding a diesel sound to my car - like a ups truck's, rhythmic chatter, but quieter. For me, the purely mechanical sound adds a cool character that I like, and that most people will assume is just part of the cars sounds.
Bottom line, I'd you're not into the tangible performance increases, you should simply NOT do it or at least, drive/ride/listen closely so a similarly equipped car.
Cheers!
The noise is ALWAYS there. Whether or not a LWFW is for you likely depends on how loud it actually is, how rhythmic the sound is (relative to orher noises, di tou gave an exhaust?) and most importantly - whether you LIKE the resultant sound.
I find it easy to characterize mine as adding a diesel sound to my car - like a ups truck's, rhythmic chatter, but quieter. For me, the purely mechanical sound adds a cool character that I like, and that most people will assume is just part of the cars sounds.
Bottom line, I'd you're not into the tangible performance increases, you should simply NOT do it or at least, drive/ride/listen closely so a similarly equipped car.
Cheers!
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 596
From: Detroit
Rep Power: 49
Great, I just plunked 2k on kevins kit because I felt your excitement
also have an offer on my clutch masters stage 3 already if this doesn't pan out, I'm coming for you ttpopo 
jk
also have an offer on my clutch masters stage 3 already if this doesn't pan out, I'm coming for you ttpopo jk
Registered User
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 2,154
Rep Power: 198
After spending a bunch of time with my newly LWFW car, I can finally understand the issue.
The noise is ALWAYS there. Whether or not a LWFW is for you likely depends on how loud it actually is, how rhythmic the sound is (relative to orher noises, di tou gave an exhaust?) and most importantly - whether you LIKE the resultant sound.
I find it easy to characterize mine as adding a diesel sound to my car - like a ups truck's, rhythmic chatter, but quieter. For me, the purely mechanical sound adds a cool character that I like, and that most people will assume is just part of the cars sounds.
Bottom line, I'd you're not into the tangible performance increases, you should simply NOT do it or at least, drive/ride/listen closely so a similarly equipped car.
Cheers!
The noise is ALWAYS there. Whether or not a LWFW is for you likely depends on how loud it actually is, how rhythmic the sound is (relative to orher noises, di tou gave an exhaust?) and most importantly - whether you LIKE the resultant sound.
I find it easy to characterize mine as adding a diesel sound to my car - like a ups truck's, rhythmic chatter, but quieter. For me, the purely mechanical sound adds a cool character that I like, and that most people will assume is just part of the cars sounds.
Bottom line, I'd you're not into the tangible performance increases, you should simply NOT do it or at least, drive/ride/listen closely so a similarly equipped car.
Cheers!
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 874
From: Hawaii
Rep Power: 72
No worries, You'll love it. I love mine
Ps - how much hp you have?
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 596
From: Detroit
Rep Power: 49
I did add some carbon fiber bits and pieces though.
Last edited by powderjay; Jan 20, 2012 at 10:58 AM.
Registered User
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 327
From: Maryland USA
Rep Power: 33
According to cm themselves all their Porsche clutches are fiber tough unless you request Kevlar. This is what they told me when I just purchased my stage3. Any of the part #'s that end in FF are fiber tough according to them.
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 596
From: Detroit
Rep Power: 49
Clutch and flywheel in! So far so good, pedal feel excellent, engagement point excellent, noise so far minimal. Hope she can handle the horse power for a LNG while and I'll be a happy camper.
Registered User
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 172
From: Quebec city
Rep Power: 23
No Porsche specific, but let me add a bit of my own experience...
I had a turbo'ed Miata and while doing the clutch I decided for a lwfw. I do blip my throttle (former F2000 racer and actual BMWCCA instructor) and I really liked how it helps heel n toe.
But the increase in power was minimal. In the Miata's case it shed some 10lbs iirc. But that's quite unsignificant. On the track where you're most everytime in the higher rpm range, it didn't really help boost at all. Just more fun to blip.
Fast forward to my 996tt, unless I unknowlingly already have a lwfw (I bought the car used), the flywheel is really not heavy at all. My 1.8L engined Lotus Elise had a much heavier fw (in feeling at least). I had to readjust my blipping at first cause I would always overshoot my heel n toe's in the 996tt... For the Porsche, no way I'd go lwfw.
So, for performance purpose only, that's a waste of money unless you are a hard core racer or regular track driver. But I suspect a hard core racer would just do it and not ask for opinions. For fun of blipping and easier HnT, ok I could see why. But the chatter/noise for me is not worth it for a street/track car. However, on a car like the WRX Sti I had, that had a very heavy flywheel, I think I'd really consider one. It really annoyed me. But not in the P.
my 0,02$
I had a turbo'ed Miata and while doing the clutch I decided for a lwfw. I do blip my throttle (former F2000 racer and actual BMWCCA instructor) and I really liked how it helps heel n toe.
But the increase in power was minimal. In the Miata's case it shed some 10lbs iirc. But that's quite unsignificant. On the track where you're most everytime in the higher rpm range, it didn't really help boost at all. Just more fun to blip.
Fast forward to my 996tt, unless I unknowlingly already have a lwfw (I bought the car used), the flywheel is really not heavy at all. My 1.8L engined Lotus Elise had a much heavier fw (in feeling at least). I had to readjust my blipping at first cause I would always overshoot my heel n toe's in the 996tt... For the Porsche, no way I'd go lwfw.
So, for performance purpose only, that's a waste of money unless you are a hard core racer or regular track driver. But I suspect a hard core racer would just do it and not ask for opinions. For fun of blipping and easier HnT, ok I could see why. But the chatter/noise for me is not worth it for a street/track car. However, on a car like the WRX Sti I had, that had a very heavy flywheel, I think I'd really consider one. It really annoyed me. But not in the P.
my 0,02$
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 874
From: Hawaii
Rep Power: 72
No Porsche specific, but let me add a bit of my own experience...
I had a turbo'ed Miata and while doing the clutch I decided for a lwfw. I do blip my throttle (former F2000 racer and actual BMWCCA instructor) and I really liked how it helps heel n toe.
But the increase in power was minimal. In the Miata's case it shed some 10lbs iirc. But that's quite unsignificant. On the track where you're most everytime in the higher rpm range, it didn't really help boost at all. Just more fun to blip.
Fast forward to my 996tt, unless I unknowlingly already have a lwfw (I bought the car used), the flywheel is really not heavy at all. My 1.8L engined Lotus Elise had a much heavier fw (in feeling at least). I had to readjust my blipping at first cause I would always overshoot my heel n toe's in the 996tt... For the Porsche, no way I'd go lwfw.
So, for performance purpose only, that's a waste of money unless you are a hard core racer or regular track driver. But I suspect a hard core racer would just do it and not ask for opinions. For fun of blipping and easier HnT, ok I could see why. But the chatter/noise for me is not worth it for a street/track car. However, on a car like the WRX Sti I had, that had a very heavy flywheel, I think I'd really consider one. It really annoyed me. But not in the P.
my 0,02$
I had a turbo'ed Miata and while doing the clutch I decided for a lwfw. I do blip my throttle (former F2000 racer and actual BMWCCA instructor) and I really liked how it helps heel n toe.
But the increase in power was minimal. In the Miata's case it shed some 10lbs iirc. But that's quite unsignificant. On the track where you're most everytime in the higher rpm range, it didn't really help boost at all. Just more fun to blip.
Fast forward to my 996tt, unless I unknowlingly already have a lwfw (I bought the car used), the flywheel is really not heavy at all. My 1.8L engined Lotus Elise had a much heavier fw (in feeling at least). I had to readjust my blipping at first cause I would always overshoot my heel n toe's in the 996tt... For the Porsche, no way I'd go lwfw.
So, for performance purpose only, that's a waste of money unless you are a hard core racer or regular track driver. But I suspect a hard core racer would just do it and not ask for opinions. For fun of blipping and easier HnT, ok I could see why. But the chatter/noise for me is not worth it for a street/track car. However, on a car like the WRX Sti I had, that had a very heavy flywheel, I think I'd really consider one. It really annoyed me. But not in the P.
my 0,02$
the lwfw on the 996tt makes your boost come on faster. thats why i love it.
Registered User
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 1,687
From: CA
Rep Power: 122
I just reverted back to OEM from LWFW bc different strategy with the car, and driving home 2 night ago with the OEM flywheel it was smooth alright but it felt like I lost 30hp and boost really felt like it came on slower. I felt like I was back with K16 instead of K24. Oh well.
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 596
From: Detroit
Rep Power: 49
Love the clutch feel so far! Only about 300 miles though. Trying to track down a boost leak with all the new parts I added in the off season. So haven't fully enjoyed the beast. Will keep ya posted!