What PSI should I be setting my tires to? No tracking(for now)

Current PSI: 33----33(front)
39----39(rear)

 

I'd go up a couple of pounds on the rears but your fronts are good.

 

I have a 2007 Turbo and run 37 front, 44 rear for regular driving.

 

I run F 31 R 35 cold which goes up to F 34-35 R 37-39 hot.

 

^^^ Agreed. 33/39 hot is the official recommendation; in California this means around 31/37 cold.
IMHO, better yet, follows the differential reading in the Turbo - this automatically adjusts to temperature, and should read around 0, with some small variation around 0 per your taste.

If anyone has to run your tires much higher than 33/39 to make the car feels "right", it's possible "your body" is telling you that the car's suspension is too soft and you are (over)-stiffening the tires to compensate for the softness in the coilover/springs/etc. Might be time to consider stiffer springs or coilover. Just MHO of course, YMMV.