2007 for the same price you are looking to spend on the 2005:

http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/2007-...item27ae9304d0

 

He's looking at an '05 S you've linked a base Carerra. While 2 years newer not set up the same so the comparison is not really relavent.

Your point that the OP could do better $ and condition wise is valid if he were to look elsewhere is spot on.