Looking for a recommendation in or close to NYC. Parking garage guys scraaaaped me badly & now need paint. I'm inclined not to try and do a touch up but rather the entire fender.

Thanks for any recommendations

 

what color is the car?

 

I would try paintless dent repair rather than replacing the fender... even if you choose to repaint the area, repairing the dent (as long as the area is manageable) is a better alternative to replacing the fender. Plus then, you don't have to explain that the car was never in an accident even though the fender has been replaced.