Against the grain... I own a 570S, Do it! You’ll love the Macs. I came from a 997.2 TTS to a Mac. On my second one.

IMHO...it depends less on performance and more about the experience you are seeking. Frankly, I believe the only area the 911 turbo lags its primary competitors is in the exotic factor. Arguably, the 911 turbo it is one of the most balanced, well engineered, sports cars in the world. I found myself searching for a new experience and opted for Lamborghini. Yes, a bit more expensive, but I find the driving experience in my Huracan 610-4 in pearl orange (Arancio Boriales) to be exciting in a level the 911 turbo can never match simply because its not that type of car. I realize your question is about Mclaren; however, I believe the correlation is similar. Cheers!

I made that exact move a year ago. I Definitely do not regret it. Both are fantastic cars but they feel very different. The McLaren feels more “special”. Every drive feels like an event. The benefits of the Porsche are it keeps a lower profile and it definitely feels more bulletproof. I never worried about taking it anywhere and it never drew too much attention. I could take it to work without concern. The McLaren is the opposite. Even without a bright color it grabs attention. I took it to a race a couple of weeks ago and had at least 100 people coming up and taking pictures with it. You may or may not like that but it’s unavoidable. People pull next to you for photos and videos on the highway all the time. It’s too flashy for me to take to work without inviting criticism I would rather avoid. That’s a down side for me.
As far as the 570GT being the “soft one” that’s a non factor. I chose the GT due to the better looks and the open feeling of the cabin with the glass. I love it. I drove both the 570s and the GT and they feel very similar on the street. The 991TTS is also a “soft one” compared to the GT3. The 570 GT is much closer to a GT3 in driving feel than the turbo. The lightweight nature of the car and the fantastic carbon tub make driving it a real joy. I personally have had zero maintenance issues so far. I wouldn’t be afraid to make the switch if I were you. I was a little apprehensive when I made the switch. I would do it again without any concerns.

Before I bought my turbo S I went to McLaren and test drove a 570 S. I really did like the car. I could not however get over the idea that the thing might break down at any point. I tend to keep my cars out of warranty and the idea of having to shell out another $400 per month to keep an extended warranty just turned me off. I guess if you were going to lease the car or never own it out of warranty and you weren’t concerned about an unclear depreciation hit, then give it a try for a few years. I am very happy with my purchase. I’m sure I would’ve been happy if I bought the McLaren as well. Best of luck and let us know how it goes.

Not sure which 570 you’re looking at, but mine is top notch!!! Body lines are close to perfect, few imperfections, and paint is truly the best I’ve ever had on any car I’ve owned. My 997 TTS had paint correction done on it and it was flawless, but this car is as close to that paint job as I’ve seen and it’s new! Owned a 650S before this car and it was pretty damned good too... so you maybe are looking at the minority of their stock?!?!?