997 Turbo / GT2 2006–2012 Turbo discussion on the 997 model Porsche 911 Twin Turbo.
Sponsored by:
Sponsored by: HBI Auto

Bilstein Alternatives?

Thread Tools
 
Rate Thread
 
Old Jan 3, 2010 | 01:47 PM
  #16  
sparkhill's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 1,252
From: Reno, NV
Rep Power: 144
sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !
FWIW, I am at -16mm (dropped and aligned by my Porsche dealer) and my Bilstein front drop links failed.

Originally Posted by TT Surgeon
I think when the drop links fail, the car has been 'slammed' too much, throwing off the geometry resulting in failure. My car is set at -15mm, set up by F-L, zero issues.
 
Old Jan 3, 2010 | 02:05 PM
  #17  
cayenne_ksa's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Jun 2005
Posts: 3,108
From: denver/Saudi
Rep Power: 165
cayenne_ksa has a reputation beyond reputecayenne_ksa has a reputation beyond reputecayenne_ksa has a reputation beyond reputecayenne_ksa has a reputation beyond reputecayenne_ksa has a reputation beyond reputecayenne_ksa has a reputation beyond reputecayenne_ksa has a reputation beyond reputecayenne_ksa has a reputation beyond reputecayenne_ksa has a reputation beyond reputecayenne_ksa has a reputation beyond reputecayenne_ksa has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by sparkhill
FWIW, I am at -16mm (dropped and aligned by my Porsche dealer) and my Bilstein front drop links failed.
is that cover under warranty ?
 
Old Jan 3, 2010 | 02:20 PM
  #18  
TTdude's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 2,321
From: Fastlane USA
Rep Power: 246
TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by bbywu
Do you not have a suspension button?
Sorry for the confusion! I have the suspension button but not the Sport button. It's all clear now. Thanks.
 
Old Jan 3, 2010 | 02:33 PM
  #19  
bbywu's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 10,774
From: OR Room 5
Rep Power: 1007
bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by TTdude
Sorry for the confusion! I have the suspension button but not the Sport button. It's all clear now. Thanks.
No problem.

Just to clarify...the "Sports" button activates Sports Chrono functions...it interlinks many features...activating PASM, throttle response, Overboost, PSM functions, etc.

If you elect to go with a non PASM compatible damper (ie Motons, KW V3s) and don't want to have a "dead" button on your console (ie a button that doesn't do anything...I hate that) you can purchase this after deactivating PASM with PIWIS.

997 613 133 00 combined switch I476

This is the lower center console switch from the 997 Carrera. You should double check with your service department, but if I'm not mistaken, this version of the console switch has a button for the wing deployment and PSM. The PASM and Sports Chrono button are missing...hence, you won't have a dead button.
 
Attached Images  
Old Jan 3, 2010 | 02:41 PM
  #20  
TTdude's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 2,321
From: Fastlane USA
Rep Power: 246
TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by bbywu
No problem.

Just to clarify...the "Sports" button activates Sports Chrono functions...it interlinks many features...activating PASM, throttle response, Overboost, PSM functions, etc.

If you elect to go with a non PASM compatible damper (ie Motons, KW V3s) and don't want to have a "dead" button on your console (ie a button that doesn't do anything...I hate that) you can purchase this after deactivating PASM with PIWIS.

997 613 133 00 combined switch I476

This is the lower center console switch from the 997 Carrera. You should double check with your service department, but if I'm not mistaken, this version of the console switch has a button for the wing deployment and PSM. The PASM and Sports Chrono button are missing...hence, you won't have a dead button.
Thanks for the suggestion, will keep that in mind. You're a much appreciated wealth of information!
 
Old Jan 3, 2010 | 03:17 PM
  #21  
sparkhill's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 1,252
From: Reno, NV
Rep Power: 144
sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by cayenne_ksa
is that cover under warranty ?
They are good guys at my dealership, but not that good. The short version of my saga is: 1) my Bilstein left front drop link broke, 2) Bilstein blew me off, 3) installed adjustable front drop links, 4) the adjustable drop links were for the 996TT (wrong geometry), 5) the vendor manufactured 997TT front drop links with the proper geometry, 6) installed the "improved" 997TT drop links, 7) the "improved" drop links loosened twice, were less sturdy and bent, 8) SharkWerks made me a set of non-adjustable front drop links which have worked flawlessly.
 
Old Jan 3, 2010 | 04:02 PM
  #22  
cannga's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 3,116
From: Palos Verdes
Rep Power: 256
cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !
Dave,

All excellent info posted here, and I agree with bbywu (yes he's a wealth of info), *if* you want something different from Bilstein, the choices narrow down to three: KW V3, JRZ, and Moton.

But... one thing I would like to add is that the key to concentrate on is not that those 3 alternatives are "better," which they are, but that they are DIFFERENT. They are stiffer and designed for a different purpose: more aggressive and track oriented, less "daily drive." I am 100% certain this is the case for JRZ and Moton, and not sure but think it applies to KW as well. The shock absorbers in these coilovers are designed for much stiffer spring rates, so it is NOT a simple matter of switching out the springs either (again, less sure about KW).

(Larry, same thing about the Techarts, "different," not necessarily better. The Techart to my best knowledge is Bilstein Damptronic with possible different spring and dampening rates. Most likely stiffer but since they are so strict about releasing data, no one knows.)

The 2 people with KW on this forum are my forum friend cayenne_ksa and my mod advisor Gotboost?. You might want to email them for opinions. I suspect that it is a more aggressive setup than Bilstein, but other than a high spring rate in the rear of around 950 (?), versus Bilstein 570, this setup is a complete unknown to me and has very few users' reports/reviews on these Porsche forums.

As for quality? Bilstein makes the OEM shock; the ones in your car now IS made by Bilstein. They also use Porsche's chief test driver, Walter Rohrl, as their consultant, etc., so the link is deep and that's why I frequently said it is like getting a factory Sport upgrade -- a safest and most no-brainer of all mods.
Not to say that it is the case, but I agree with TT Surgeon in the sense that I would not rule out installer's error in that other particular case either. I am curious myself.
The popping drop link? My installer did say something similar to TT Surgeon's post: if you catch/slam the suspension at a correct "perfect storm" angle, the link will pop. But I think sparkhill's ones just popped, do agree that it should be better made, and did get extra ones similar to sparkhill's just in case mines do :-). Do keep in mind the vast majority of links have not popped.
(cayenne_ksa, I believe you were asking about Bilstein warranty? Lifetime. And they are KNOWN for incredible and generous service. They will give you a lifetime supply of drop links ; it's just a mild pain in the derriere to change.)

In the end, my opinion is the key to remember is that the alternative coilovers are different, not just better or worse. For track or more aggressive setup, yes consider KW, JRZ, and Moton; or change the Bilstein valving and spring rates as in the excellent works by TPC/Techarts/etc. Bilstein itself makes more aggressive shock than the Damptronic.
But... if you drive the cars frequently on bad roads, and if you daily drive the car, or if you are a more "gentle" type of driver, then stay with the safe choice.

 

Last edited by cannga; Jan 3, 2010 at 04:26 PM.
Old Jan 3, 2010 | 04:14 PM
  #23  
VAGtuner's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 49
From: Atlantic coast
Rep Power: 18
VAGtuner is infamous around these parts
KW Suspension has no doubt proven themselves to have an excellent reputation. In addition, Koni makes great suspension products, such as those used on many Ferrari models.
 
Old Jan 3, 2010 | 04:33 PM
  #24  
TT Gasman's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 1,989
From: Texas
Rep Power: 117
TT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant future
Other alternatives include the H&R race parts (not the OTC street stuff), and Pen$ke.
 
Old Jan 3, 2010 | 04:35 PM
  #25  
bbywu's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 10,774
From: OR Room 5
Rep Power: 1007
bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by TT Gasman
Other alternatives include the H&R race parts (not the OTC street stuff), and Pen$ke.
lol
 
Old Jan 3, 2010 | 04:39 PM
  #26  
bbywu's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 10,774
From: OR Room 5
Rep Power: 1007
bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !bbywu Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by sparkhill
FWIW, I am at -16mm (dropped and aligned by my Porsche dealer) and my Bilstein front drop links failed.
As did mine.

If you look at aftermarket drop links that use aluminum rod ends, they stretch over time. There is no doubt in my mind that the plastic insert on the Damptronics are not up to the task for any reduction in ride height.
 
Old Jan 3, 2010 | 04:58 PM
  #27  
TT Gasman's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 1,989
From: Texas
Rep Power: 117
TT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant futureTT Gasman has a brilliant future
How about Gt2/3 drop links? Has anyone tried these yet?
 
Old Jan 3, 2010 | 06:17 PM
  #28  
landjet's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 3,633
From: Maryland
Rep Power: 277
landjet Is a GOD !landjet Is a GOD !landjet Is a GOD !landjet Is a GOD !landjet Is a GOD !landjet Is a GOD !landjet Is a GOD !landjet Is a GOD !landjet Is a GOD !landjet Is a GOD !landjet Is a GOD !
Look into the TRG drop links. On my car, no noise and very stout.
 
Old Jan 3, 2010 | 07:09 PM
  #29  
sparkhill's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 1,252
From: Reno, NV
Rep Power: 144
sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !
My RSS front drop links bent after about 400 miles. Initially, I received the incorrect 996TT version which are much beefier than the 997TT version. RSS customer service was top-notch. RSS sent the 997TT version and even paid for the re-install labor. The 997TT version were installed without thread-lock and loosened twice.

So after my third trip for drop link service I decided I wanted something that did not have to worry about and ended up with the modified SharkLinks (stock drop links shortened and re-welded in the proper orientation). I did not even contact RSS about the bent drop links, but I am sure they would have made every effort to take corrective action. I do not know if the drop links bent because they are less sturdy than the 996TT versions, because they loosened, because they were and early production version, or some other combination of factors. Again, I am not bashing RSS - they have great products and service. I am just further explaining the reason I went in a different direction.


 
Old Jan 3, 2010 | 07:11 PM
  #30  
sparkhill's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 1,252
From: Reno, NV
Rep Power: 144
sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !sparkhill Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by TT Gasman
How about Gt2/3 drop links? Has anyone tried these yet?
I think these are modified stock TT drop links. Are they similar to the stock GT3 drop links?

 


You have already rated this thread Rating: Thread Rating: 0 votes,  average.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:25 PM.