So after doing some research, we're trying to decide between getting the WeatherTech liner, or the Cargo-Logic mat+organizer.

Seems like a lot of people love the fit, raised lip, and protection of the WeatherTech, but the Cargo-Logic mat+organizer looks very useful to hold things in place, especially in the absence of the stock cargo management system. Also wondering if a flap to cover the rear bumper is absolutely necessary, or more of an inconvenience?

Any thoughts and/or experiences?

WeatherTech
http://www.carid.com/2008-porsche-ca...er-213872.html

Cargo-Logic Mat & Organizers
http://www.carid.com/custom-floor-ma...ks-196829.html
http://www.carid.com/custom-floor-ma...rs-174025.html

 

We purchased the WeatherTech Cargo Liner for my dad for Father's Day. He loves the raised lip feature and the fact that it is custom fit to the back of his vehicle. He had a mystery spill back there before which made us all agree he needed something better than old towels back there protecting his car...something easy to clean too.

 

We also offer a compartment liner to protect your trunk area from damage, dirt, and debris with one of these heavy duty trunk liners. These liners are designed to take a beating, and the textured material helps you get a grip on your cargo, and keep it from sliding around. For more information Click Here.