I have been searching for a luxury suv and have fallen in love with the cayenne. I found 2 that are a great deal but need help deciding which to buy. The first is an 05 6cyl with 19k miles and the second is an 04 S fully loaded with 32k miles. The S just ran out of fact. warranty and has a rear accident report on the carfax but it was just the bumper cover and was repaired perfect.

Which do you feel is the better buy?

 

tough one... I want to say S but the carfax is shying me away from it... keep searching Im sure you can find another S for a good price!

 

Ya, it scares me a little too. I checked everything over and even with prior bodyshop experience, I could not tell there was paintwork. I have in writing that it was just the bumper cover.