Car 1 between the two. At the end of the day if you are spending a significant amount of money for a vehicle, get one that you truly enjoy. Do not feel like you need to settle for 1 out of 2 because its just available. The right car comes along, sometimes you just need to be patient especially a CGT. Good luck in your search.

 

don't buy one with any stories, especially a car at that level. it just makes selling it that much more difficult. the miles should not be an issue if the car is clean. just make sure the price you are paying reflects the mileage on the car.

 

More miles if the service history is perfect and condition is perfect is always going to be better than a car with accident history. Especially when we are talking about a carbon fiber Carrera GT. No way to know to what level the damage was and how close to factory the fender repair made the car.

Congratulation I envy your position, to chose which one of the best production Porsche of all times!

 

Keep looking... wait for a car that you feel 100% positive about.