With non Porsche factory warranties, it's best to talk to your local Porsche dealers service dept. and ask them about their experiences with different companies. After all, they're the ones having to make claims for reimbursement. Correct? They should know which companies stand behind their policies the best.

 

OK I found a 2013 991 CPO C2S with 20K miles, well optioned with the options I want. Dealer asking for 93K. Original MSRP was around 120K

Would 90K be a fair price or should I try for less?

 

It's overpriced. If it had less than 8,000 miles it would be about right. Plenty of lower mileage cars out there.

Not worth a dime over 85K and that's even generous.