997 Turbo / GT2 2006–2012 Turbo discussion on the 997 model Porsche 911 Twin Turbo.
Sponsored by:
Sponsored by: HBI Auto

Introduction: AMT Tech1 Forged Monoblock Wheels

Thread Tools
 
Rate Thread
 
Old Nov 9, 2008 | 03:11 AM
  #31  
GT RUS's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 1,456
From: Russia
Rep Power: 81
GT RUS is just really niceGT RUS is just really niceGT RUS is just really niceGT RUS is just really niceGT RUS is just really nice
I think about chargoal on GT Silver 997 TT...any pics ???
 

Last edited by GT RUS; Nov 9, 2008 at 03:15 AM.
Old Nov 9, 2008 | 06:44 AM
  #32  
imcarnuts's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 1,945
From: Pittsburgh Area
Rep Power: 171
imcarnuts Is a GOD !imcarnuts Is a GOD !imcarnuts Is a GOD !imcarnuts Is a GOD !imcarnuts Is a GOD !imcarnuts Is a GOD !imcarnuts Is a GOD !imcarnuts Is a GOD !imcarnuts Is a GOD !imcarnuts Is a GOD !imcarnuts Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by Forgedwheeler
AMT has been a forged wheel manufacturer for more than a decade.
They supply many USA defense-oriented suppliers with wheels for military and aerospace applications. These are mission-critical projects like bomb disposal vehicles, armored vehicles and the like.
In addition, the company is the exclusive forged wheel supplier to Roush. Internationally, they supply Brabus, Gemballa, Kahn, Winchester, Overfinch and along list of the world's top tuners on a private-label basis.
This is their first AMT branded product and it is substantially less expensive than HRE and most of its competitors. The value proposition is underscored by the fact their product is comparable in weight to a carbon fiber wheel at half the price and with NONE of the problems.
And yes, I do work for AMT.
That explains a lot - in a good way. You have had some very informative posts in the past, and I wondered where your expertise came from. Keep the technical info coming. Thanks. Nice wheels also.
 
Old Nov 9, 2008 | 10:12 AM
  #33  
Wheel Experts's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Basic Sponsor
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 5,110
From: Dallas, TX
Rep Power: 0
Wheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by GT RUS
I think about chargoal on GT Silver 997 TT...any pics ???
no pics of charcoal yet..... coming soon
 
Old Nov 9, 2008 | 05:16 PM
  #34  
cannga's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 3,116
From: Palos Verdes
Rep Power: 256
cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !
Wow, all of sudden these EXCELLENT wheels appear. Potential buyers note that AMT significantly underweigh both HRE P40 and Champion 171. The mesh wheel (109) looks "funny," too squarish. But the 10 spoke (110) wheel looks good.

Just 4 things to point out, and maybe Peter/Forgedwheeler could answer for potential buyers:

1. OEM rear rim width is 11, not 11.5 like these AMT's.
2. Is center cap compatible with the Porsche cap?
3. Is this TPMS compatible?
4. Are spacers needed for the Porsche Turbo?

At any rate, congrats to AMT. These are VERY VERY light wheels. Competition is good indeed.

Name:  WheelsWeight.jpg
Views: 291
Size:  29.0 KB
Originally Posted by peter@wheelexperts
Wheel Experts is proud to announce the introduction of AMT "Tech1" Forged Monoblock Wheels for Porsche. The wheels are made in the good ol' USA of 100% aerospace grade aluminum and are extremely lightweight. Initially, there will be 2 styles available, a mesh (Style 109) and a 10 spoke (Style 110), with more to come, and are available in the following sizes, followed by a nominal weight (+/- .5 lbs depending on exact style and finish)

19x8.5 - 17 lbs
19x11.5 - 21.5 lbs
19x12 - 22.5 lbs (GT3, GT3RS)
20x8.5 - 18.5 lbs
20x11 - 22 lbs
20x12 - 24 lbs

.....
peter@wheelexperts.com

Thanks!





 

Last edited by cannga; Nov 9, 2008 at 05:25 PM.
Old Nov 9, 2008 | 05:33 PM
  #35  
Wheel Experts's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Basic Sponsor
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 5,110
From: Dallas, TX
Rep Power: 0
Wheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond reputeWheel Experts has a reputation beyond repute
Hi cannga,

The wheels are of course TPMS and OE centercap compatible. On our next photoshoot we will shoot with the OE porsche caps in place.

No spacers are needed on any application, including GT3 and GT3RS. All applications are direct bolt.

The OEM width is indeed 11, did I state otherwise? If so, my apologies. The OE setup is a 19x8 and 19x11, while AMT is 8.5 and 11.5. I believe Champion and HRE's setup is as such as well. They fit nicely on the OE 235/35/19 and 305/30/19.
 
Old Nov 9, 2008 | 07:30 PM
  #36  
Tech1_Mike's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 642
From: Kansas
Rep Power: 79
Tech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by cannga
Wow, all of sudden these EXCELLENT wheels appear. Potential buyers note that AMT significantly underweigh both HRE P40 and Champion 171. The mesh wheel (109) looks "funny," too squarish. But the 10 spoke (110) wheel looks good.

Just 4 things to point out, and maybe Peter/Forgedwheeler could answer for potential buyers:

1. OEM rear rim width is 11, not 11.5 like these AMT's.
2. Is center cap compatible with the Porsche cap?
3. Is this TPMS compatible?
4. Are spacers needed for the Porsche Turbo?

At any rate, congrats to AMT. These are VERY VERY light wheels. Competition is good indeed.

"Competition is, indeed, a wonderful thing."
Jack Welch, CEO
General Electric

Jack created more than $100 billion of shareholder value
 
Old Nov 10, 2008 | 03:58 PM
  #37  
carlover08's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 190
From: World
Rep Power: 25
carlover08 is infamous around these parts
I was trying to find some more information on the wheel quality compared to others and I came upon this from another thread. I think its good for us enthusiasts
https://www.6speedonline.com/forums/...-wheels-3.html

HRE_Alan
Registered User

Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Vista, CA
Age: 39
Posts: 2
Agreed!! (almost...)
Benjamin,

I agree with you wholeheartedly (except for your criticism of us of course!!)

It is unfortunate that in one breath HRE is criticized for making wheels that are "too heavy" while our "competition" is applauded for making wheels that are irresponsibly light weight. And now we introduce a material that can get us to a lower weight safely and we're being criticized.

If you notice, the weights of our 1pc forged aluminum wheels are in-line with our quality competitors, namely BBS and Champion. Why is this? It's because the same physics that apply to them apply to me. I can make a 17lb wheel any day of the week, but that doesn't mean it is safe to go on a 997TT. Oh... but they've tested it. Not enough. It turns out that it helps if you test to the correct load rating for the application and the use the right spec. We actually multiply the designated TUV load rating by a factor of safety before designing the wheel to that spec. Why? We've found that simply going off of max axle load isn't enough. Not even close. If it were that easy to make them lightweight, wouldn't Porsche do it themselves? Do any of us have more resources than Porsche? I don't think so.

This shows the difference between good marketing and good engineering. We'll stick to the good engineering. We want to be in business for the long haul. We're not going to sell a bunch of wheels and then going running off with all the money once the fatigure failures begin... and they will begin. It just takes time.

So on to carbon. It turns out that the stiffness of the carbon barrel is actually much higher than the stiffness of the aluminum barrel. In fact, in fatigue, the barrels are load rated MUCH higher than the aluminum center simply because you have to design the rim around impact. Okay... so is it brittle and is it going to shatter into a million pieces under impact. Nope. If you hit a curb or something you'll definitely damage it, but you'll have a localized failure which is what you want and should expect.

As for us not knowing and/or not caring, I want to extend an invitation to you to visit HRE anytime. I can give you a personal tour (above and beyond my normal tours) and show you how we do it and why we do it that way. I think you'll be impressed by our knowledge and expertise, our capabilities, our honesty and the most of all the integrity that is simply infused in all of us here.

If you want to criticize us after that, feel free. I welcome constructive criticism. It keeps us moving forward. I just prefer it is based on facts and reality.

My $.51.

Thanks,

Alan
 
Old Nov 10, 2008 | 04:43 PM
  #38  
HRE_Alan's Avatar
Former Vendor
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 148
From: Vista, CA
Rep Power: 0
HRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant future
Thanks, but...

carlover08,

Thanks but my post was in response to concerns about carbon so I appreciate the help, but I can handle it. Since I see HRE's name in this thread everywhere if anyone has any questions about why our wheels weigh what they weigh, go ahead and contact me directly. I'll give you the facts about wheel design.

760-598-1960

Thanks,

Alan

Originally Posted by carlover08
I was trying to find some more information on the wheel quality compared to others and I came upon this from another thread. I think its good for us enthusiasts
https://www.6speedonline.com/forums/...-wheels-3.html

HRE_Alan
Registered User

Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Vista, CA
Age: 39
Posts: 2
Agreed!! (almost...)
Benjamin,

I agree with you wholeheartedly (except for your criticism of us of course!!)

It is unfortunate that in one breath HRE is criticized for making wheels that are "too heavy" while our "competition" is applauded for making wheels that are irresponsibly light weight. And now we introduce a material that can get us to a lower weight safely and we're being criticized.

If you notice, the weights of our 1pc forged aluminum wheels are in-line with our quality competitors, namely BBS and Champion. Why is this? It's because the same physics that apply to them apply to me. I can make a 17lb wheel any day of the week, but that doesn't mean it is safe to go on a 997TT. Oh... but they've tested it. Not enough. It turns out that it helps if you test to the correct load rating for the application and the use the right spec. We actually multiply the designated TUV load rating by a factor of safety before designing the wheel to that spec. Why? We've found that simply going off of max axle load isn't enough. Not even close. If it were that easy to make them lightweight, wouldn't Porsche do it themselves? Do any of us have more resources than Porsche? I don't think so.

This shows the difference between good marketing and good engineering. We'll stick to the good engineering. We want to be in business for the long haul. We're not going to sell a bunch of wheels and then going running off with all the money once the fatigure failures begin... and they will begin. It just takes time.

So on to carbon. It turns out that the stiffness of the carbon barrel is actually much higher than the stiffness of the aluminum barrel. In fact, in fatigue, the barrels are load rated MUCH higher than the aluminum center simply because you have to design the rim around impact. Okay... so is it brittle and is it going to shatter into a million pieces under impact. Nope. If you hit a curb or something you'll definitely damage it, but you'll have a localized failure which is what you want and should expect.

As for us not knowing and/or not caring, I want to extend an invitation to you to visit HRE anytime. I can give you a personal tour (above and beyond my normal tours) and show you how we do it and why we do it that way. I think you'll be impressed by our knowledge and expertise, our capabilities, our honesty and the most of all the integrity that is simply infused in all of us here.

If you want to criticize us after that, feel free. I welcome constructive criticism. It keeps us moving forward. I just prefer it is based on facts and reality.

My $.51.

Thanks,

Alan
 
Old Nov 10, 2008 | 05:38 PM
  #39  
cannga's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 3,116
From: Palos Verdes
Rep Power: 256
cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !cannga Is a GOD !
Excellent point. Your expertise is appreciated. I guess lighter doesn't necessarily mean better?

The only exception to what you said though, is Champion does make a very light 1 piece forged wheel, the RG5. It would have been my top choice except for the fact that it has lip, and I strongly prefer my HRE P40's design -- to my eyes the best mesh design currently on the market.

Name:  WheelsWeight.jpg
Views: 303
Size:  29.0 KB

Originally Posted by HRE_Alan
If you notice, the weights of our 1pc forged aluminum wheels are in-line with our quality competitors, namely BBS and Champion. Why is this? It's because the same physics that apply to them apply to me. I can make a 17lb wheel any day of the week, but that doesn't mean it is safe to go on a 997TT. Oh... but they've tested it. Not enough. It turns out that it helps if you test to the correct load rating for the application and the use the right spec. We actually multiply the designated TUV load rating by a factor of safety before designing the wheel to that spec. Why? We've found that simply going off of max axle load isn't enough. Not even close. If it were that easy to make them lightweight, wouldn't Porsche do it themselves? Do any of us have more resources than Porsche? I don't think so.
 

Last edited by cannga; Nov 10, 2008 at 05:40 PM.
Old Nov 10, 2008 | 06:06 PM
  #40  
Tech1_Mike's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 642
From: Kansas
Rep Power: 79
Tech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by HRE_Alan
carlover08,

Thanks but my post was in response to concerns about carbon so I appreciate the help, but I can handle it. Since I see HRE's name in this thread everywhere if anyone has any questions about why our wheels weigh what they weigh, go ahead and contact me directly. I'll give you the facts about wheel design.

760-598-1960

Thanks,

Alan
We have great respect for HRE and Mr. Peltier. For the record, no one at AMT has ever criticized HRE for how they choose to build their monoblock wheels, or their product's inertia weight. We would consider that especially inappropriate in a new product announcement thread on this forum.
However, to address Mr. Peltier's comments, our technology, equipment and manufacturing techniques are superior to anything HRE has to offer. We have been building forged monoblock wheels for a decade and private label them to some of the finest automotive tuners in the world. We supply the military and aerospace industries with exotic, high strength alloy wheels and components. For years, we supplied Dodge with forged wheels for the Viper program. We are the exclusive forged wheel supplier to Roush.
We forge, spin, heat-treat, lathe and mill all of our our own wheels in our own 120,000 sq. ft. factory in Oxnard, California. And we have vast experience with aluminum alloys far stronger than that used by our competitors.
HRE, in stark comparison, buys a spun blank from a third party, cuts a style on a milling machine, and then wants to sell you that they alone understand wheel engineering.
The AMT Forged Alloys product line is carefully engineered, weight-optimized, properly load rated, comes with a one-year road hazard warranty and a lifetime structural warranty.
Lastly, and most importantly, no AMT product has ever experienced a structural failure in service and no AMT product has ever been recalled.
We think you will have a tough time finding another wheel manufacturer who can make that claim.


Mike Burroughs
816/588-3153
 
Old Nov 10, 2008 | 06:25 PM
  #41  
HRE_Alan's Avatar
Former Vendor
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 148
From: Vista, CA
Rep Power: 0
HRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant futureHRE_Alan has a brilliant future
I never mentioned AMT.

Mike,

For the record, I never mentioned AMT and I didn't post in response to AMT. In comparison, you've been posting for months about HRE acting like you're just a guy looking out for everyone's best interest. Interesting strategy to say the least. You're a sales guy and I'm an engineer. We just see things differently and do things differently. We'll never agree. I'm very comfortable with that relationship.

I ask everyone to please visit AMT and visit HRE. I welcome the comparison. There is more to a company than the size of your facility or whether or not you make your own forgings. Champion doesn't even make their own wheels, but we all agree they're a high quality product. In the end, I know what makes HRE special. It isn't just the technical stuff (which we do well by the way). It's the people. Anybody that has ever met us knows the type of people we are and how that reflects on the products we make. You can't find that many places.

Have fun. Welcome to the party. Good luck with your wheels.

Alan

Originally Posted by Forgedwheeler
We have great respect for HRE and Mr. Peltier. For the record, no one at AMT has ever criticized HRE for how they choose to build their monoblock wheels, or their product's inertia weight. We would consider that especially inappropriate in a new product announcement thread on this forum.
However, to address Mr. Peltier's comments, our technology, equipment and manufacturing techniques are superior to anything HRE has to offer. We have been building forged monoblock wheels for a decade and private label them to some of the finest automotive tuners in the world. We supply the military and aerospace industries with exotic, high strength alloy wheels and components. For years, we supplied Dodge with forged wheels for the Viper program. We are the exclusive forged wheel supplier to Roush.
We forge, spin, heat-treat, lathe and mill all of our our own wheels in our own 120,000 sq. ft. factory in Oxnard, California. And we have vast experience with aluminum alloys far stronger than that used by our competitors.
HRE, in stark comparison, buys a spun blank from a third party, cuts a style on a milling machine, and then wants to sell you that they alone understand wheel engineering.
The AMT Forged Alloys product line is carefully engineered, weight-optimized, properly load rated, comes with a one-year road hazard warranty and a lifetime structural warranty.
Lastly, and most importantly, no AMT product has ever experienced a structural failure in service and no AMT product has ever been recalled.
We think you will have a tough time finding another wheel manufacturer who can make that claim.


Mike Burroughs
816/588-3153
 
Old Nov 10, 2008 | 06:49 PM
  #42  
Tech1_Mike's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 642
From: Kansas
Rep Power: 79
Tech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond reputeTech1_Mike has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by HRE_Alan
Mike,

For the record, I never mentioned AMT and I didn't post in response to AMT. In comparison, you've been posting for months about HRE acting like you're just a guy looking out for everyone's best interest. Interesting strategy to say the least. You're a sales guy and I'm an engineer. We just see things differently and do things differently. We'll never agree. I'm very comfortable with that relationship.

I ask everyone to please visit AMT and visit HRE. I welcome the comparison. There is more to a company than the size of your facility or whether or not you make your own forgings. Champion doesn't even make their own wheels, but we all agree they're a high quality product. In the end, I know what makes HRE special. It isn't just the technical stuff (which we do well by the way). It's the people. Anybody that has ever met us knows the type of people we are and how that reflects on the products we make. You can't find that many places.

Have fun. Welcome to the party. Good luck with your wheels.

Alan
Thank you for the welcome. I have long been a fan of HRE, its products and its philosophy.
As anyone who reads my posts will attest, I consider your company a genuine industry leader.
 
Old Nov 11, 2008 | 12:13 PM
  #43  
Brett B's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 166
From: Ohio
Rep Power: 26
Brett B is infamous around these parts
Originally Posted by Forgedwheeler
However, to address Mr. Peltier's comments, our technology, equipment and manufacturing techniques are superior to anything HRE has to offer.

Mike Burroughs
816/588-3153
Mike,

Can you please provide some further info to quantify these statements regarding mass vs strength? Anything relating to differences in forging processes, alloys used, FEA modeling techniques, load/factor of safety applied, etc, would be great for those of us looking to separate facts from marketing speak.

Thanks,
Brett
 
Old Nov 11, 2008 | 12:18 PM
  #44  
gmoney's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 3,315
From: WA state
Rep Power: 197
gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by HREMarc
we have always offered aluminum powdercoated caps.
Nice, I have not seen these in action, most of the dark wheels on cars I have seen featured the regular old non matching caps!
 
Old Nov 11, 2008 | 12:33 PM
  #45  
gmoney's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 3,315
From: WA state
Rep Power: 197
gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !gmoney Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by Forgedwheeler
AMT has been a forged wheel manufacturer for more than a decade.
They supply many USA defense-oriented suppliers with wheels for military and aerospace applications. These are mission-critical projects like bomb disposal vehicles, armored vehicles and the like.
In addition, the company is the exclusive forged wheel supplier to Roush. Internationally, they supply Brabus, Gemballa, Kahn, Winchester, Overfinch and along list of the world's top tuners on a private-label basis.
This is their first AMT branded product and it is substantially less expensive than HRE and most of its competitors. The value proposition is underscored by the fact their product is comparable in weight to a carbon fiber wheel at half the price and with NONE of the problems.
And yes, I do work for AMT.
.....and amazingly they are not located in Miami like every other freaking wheel company it seems.
 


You have already rated this thread Rating: Thread Rating: 0 votes,  average.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:04 AM.