Deciding between custom: 991 4S or V8 Vantage S
building a c4s at 170k msrp? that is one loaded up Carrera! go with what fits your tastes best. I looked at the vantage. great car, very different personality than a 991. also, you are right to consider cost of ownership. Astons in my town run about $1k for an oil change. :O
Also I was paying just under $1k per year for full coverage w/$500 deductible. I had a '07 997 turbo before my '09 Vantage....I really liked the Vantage, it drew tons of attention though (good or bad...you decide)....absolutely beautiful, BUT here I am back in a 911 and loving it!!!
That would be nice...I had 2 services done on mine. One in Michigan cost $1800 and one done in Scottsdale AZ which was $2300
Also I was paying just under $1k per year for full coverage w/$500 deductible. I had a '07 997 turbo before my '09 Vantage....I really liked the Vantage, it drew tons of attention though (good or bad...you decide)....absolutely beautiful, BUT here I am back in a 911 and loving it!!!
Also I was paying just under $1k per year for full coverage w/$500 deductible. I had a '07 997 turbo before my '09 Vantage....I really liked the Vantage, it drew tons of attention though (good or bad...you decide)....absolutely beautiful, BUT here I am back in a 911 and loving it!!!
Interesting indeed. As you found out, much better rates available for both cars. I think the Aston is a great looking ride. Can someone with one explain what's involved with the ~2k oil change?
I thought the Aston was beautiful. Considered it. Read tons of reviews. Watched youtube videos. I chose the Porsche because it is a "better" car. A link to my build is in my footer. As you can probably see, the price was not a deciding factor. I feel I made the right choice. In the end though, it is your choice to make. You will have a beautiful car either way.
The Vantage is a beautiful but the car itself is just dated. The platform is a decade old and the 2011 Vantage I drove before getting my 911 did not feel any faster than my Audi S5. That and the depreciation was worse than the Porsche. Its an emotional decision to buy a Aston kind of like the Maserati Grantursimo. If that is what you want that is what you should get...We are a little biased here in the Porsche forum. Either way let us know which way you go.
aston depreciation is terrible. dont evey buy a new one as youll lose 50k after the first year of ownership. I bought a 2009 that was a year old with 5k miles for about 110k. The car was 150k new. The auto clutch on the aston is terrible. it lurchs and jumps all over the place. I purchased a 6 speed manual. Shifting was smooth on the manual but the clutch was week even after i installed a new one. It couldnt take any hard driving without smelling like ****. Nice car for the weekends. I would never purchase one as a daily driver.
aston depreciation is terrible. dont evey buy a new one as youll lose 50k after the first year of ownership. I bought a 2009 that was a year old with 5k miles for about 110k. The car was 150k new. The auto clutch on the aston is terrible. it lurchs and jumps all over the place. I purchased a 6 speed manual. Shifting was smooth on the manual but the clutch was week even after i installed a new one. It couldnt take any hard driving without smelling like ****. Nice car for the weekends. I would never purchase one as a daily driver.
building a c4s at 170k msrp? that is one loaded up Carrera! go with what fits your tastes best. I looked at the vantage. great car, very different personality than a 991. also, you are right to consider cost of ownership. Astons in my town run about $1k for an oil change. :O
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post





