996 Turbo / GT2 Turbo discussion on previous model 2000-2005 Porsche 911 Twin Turbo and 911 GT2.

Standalone or not to standalone

Thread Tools
 
Rate Thread
 
Old Feb 6, 2011 | 10:29 PM
  #16  
AWD Motorsports's Avatar
Former Vendor
Joined: Nov 2009
Posts: 1,183
From: South Florida
Rep Power: 0
AWD Motorsports Is a GOD !AWD Motorsports Is a GOD !AWD Motorsports Is a GOD !AWD Motorsports Is a GOD !AWD Motorsports Is a GOD !AWD Motorsports Is a GOD !AWD Motorsports Is a GOD !AWD Motorsports Is a GOD !AWD Motorsports Is a GOD !AWD Motorsports Is a GOD !AWD Motorsports Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by TTdude
Perhaps I'm missing something here but the motronic is a really sophisticated ECU so I'm not really seeing the advantage of a standalone especially at the power levels being described? What's the advantange of running a standalone vs tuning the DME?
Well it all depends on goals with the car.. For most applications its not needed.. However if you want Anti Lag Launch Control, Nitrous control, Staged 12 injectors, No Lift Shift w/o Egas Interference, etc its needed.. Much of the reason the Cup Cars run Motec..

Mike
 
Old Feb 6, 2011 | 10:36 PM
  #17  
TTdude's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 2,321
From: Fastlane USA
Rep Power: 246
TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !TTdude Is a GOD !
Thanks Mike! Can you still enable knock sensors with Motec or other standalones?
 

Last edited by TTdude; Feb 6, 2011 at 10:48 PM.
Old Feb 7, 2011 | 01:13 AM
  #18  
Powell's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 3,475
From: Friendswood, TX
Rep Power: 385
Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !
Standalone is the only way to go in my opinion... Just takes a little work to get it all done
 
Old Feb 7, 2011 | 06:42 AM
  #19  
Tim941NYC's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,319
From: Long island NY
Rep Power: 381
Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by TTdude
Perhaps I'm missing something here but the motronic is a really sophisticated ECU so I'm not really seeing the advantage of a standalone especially at the power levels being described? What's the advantange of running a standalone vs tuning the DME?
I make 900 on the rear wheels now. The motronic is fighting with me every step of the way. The fuel maps do not control large injectors well enough and driving part throttle is not smooth. Plus the whole MAF system is robbing free hp too. I can go on and on. I do plan on piggy backing to the factory to get passed the NY state inspection.
 
Old Feb 7, 2011 | 06:43 AM
  #20  
Tim941NYC's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,319
From: Long island NY
Rep Power: 381
Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by TTdude
Thanks Mike! Can you still enable knock sensors with Motec or other standalones?
Yes and more.
 
Old Feb 7, 2011 | 08:31 AM
  #21  
onelove's Avatar
Former Vendor
15 Year Member
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 2,023
From: Orlando, FL
Rep Power: 0
onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !
Having done this and looking back, If I were to do it again I would go full stand-alone vs piggy back standalone (with custom harness / dash / etc). This way you're making the most out of the unit and available with appropriate sensors to monitor on all the available channels.

As far as which unit to go with, Motec is really the only option when it comes to reliability and an open end software that can do nearly anything and everything. There is a reason the ALMS and Grand Am teams are still using Motec for Data even after being required to run Bosch ECU's.
 
Old Feb 7, 2011 | 08:37 AM
  #22  
Neil Switzer's Avatar
Former Vendor
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 1,387
From: Oberlin, NE Ohio
Rep Power: 0
Neil Switzer Is a GOD !Neil Switzer Is a GOD !Neil Switzer Is a GOD !Neil Switzer Is a GOD !Neil Switzer Is a GOD !Neil Switzer Is a GOD !Neil Switzer Is a GOD !Neil Switzer Is a GOD !Neil Switzer Is a GOD !Neil Switzer Is a GOD !Neil Switzer Is a GOD !
Tim, sending you an email...
 
Old Feb 7, 2011 | 11:16 AM
  #23  
onelove's Avatar
Former Vendor
15 Year Member
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 2,023
From: Orlando, FL
Rep Power: 0
onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !onelove Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by Cpais
That kinda sucks for everyone here that all those race teams are still using the Motecs for data. I was sure once they were forced to convert to the Bosch units that there would be a ton of Motecs on the market with lots of open channels for a great price. Were those guys using Motec ignition boxes, and if so, are they still using them or are they selling them all used?
Believe the change happened a year or so ago and most hit the secondary market already. I know a few resellers who scooped up all they could for resale at the time.
 
Old Feb 7, 2011 | 12:18 PM
  #24  
Powell's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 3,475
From: Friendswood, TX
Rep Power: 385
Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !
Heard HKS units work very well as well. I know of a black Porsche that has ABS/PSM and NO CEL's with one powering it. There is also a silver one that the new owner doesn't post on the forums that is running one as well. Same guy is behind it and has been doing it over 2 years. Watching him install the black cars one and tuning it is not an easy feat considering his tuning background is far ahead of most.

Unless you are going for HUGE power (1200-1300rwhp) you should be able to get away on the stock DME. I was running 1000cc injectors on the stock DME and I think Tony could tune for the 160lb injectors that I am running now. Plus with the high imp. injectors available now you don't need to worry about running a standalone so you can run a big lb/hr injector that is low imp.
 
Old Feb 7, 2011 | 02:58 PM
  #25  
markski@markskituning's Avatar
Basic Sponsor
20 Year Member
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 9,730
From: CHICAGO
Rep Power: 604
markski@markskituning Is a GOD !markski@markskituning Is a GOD !markski@markskituning Is a GOD !markski@markskituning Is a GOD !markski@markskituning Is a GOD !markski@markskituning Is a GOD !markski@markskituning Is a GOD !markski@markskituning Is a GOD !markski@markskituning Is a GOD !markski@markskituning Is a GOD !markski@markskituning Is a GOD !
We do not have any issues with the blow thru... 1000 rwhp + no problem.... I can see a problem on a stock maf... we actually did a no maf and compared it to the blow thru... such little gains that it was not even worth it... using the blow thru changes the tables sucg that you can actually dial in yout timing and afrs becasue the engine load actually is within range unlike the stock maf maps...
just a thought...
 
__________________

2001 996TT 3.6L and stock ECU
9.66
seconds @ 147.76 mph 1/4 mile
click to view
160 mph @ 9.77 seconds in 1/4 mile click to view
50% OFF ON PORSCHE ECU TUNING BLACK FRIDAY SPECIAL




Old Feb 7, 2011 | 07:48 PM
  #26  
Tim941NYC's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,319
From: Long island NY
Rep Power: 381
Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by Powell
Heard HKS units work very well as well. I know of a black Porsche that has ABS/PSM and NO CEL's with one powering it. There is also a silver one that the new owner doesn't post on the forums that is running one as well. Same guy is behind it and has been doing it over 2 years. Watching him install the black cars one and tuning it is not an easy feat considering his tuning background is far ahead of most.

Unless you are going for HUGE power (1200-1300rwhp) you should be able to get away on the stock DME. I was running 1000cc injectors on the stock DME and I think Tony could tune for the 160lb injectors that I am running now. Plus with the high imp. injectors available now you don't need to worry about running a standalone so you can run a big lb/hr injector that is low imp.
Not to sound brash but Who is making 1200-1300 rwhp on a stock 996 DME here? Drag times and car weights to prove dyno numbers.
 
Old Feb 7, 2011 | 07:51 PM
  #27  
unvmy996's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 7,481
Rep Power: 707
unvmy996 Is a GOD !unvmy996 Is a GOD !unvmy996 Is a GOD !unvmy996 Is a GOD !unvmy996 Is a GOD !unvmy996 Is a GOD !unvmy996 Is a GOD !unvmy996 Is a GOD !unvmy996 Is a GOD !unvmy996 Is a GOD !unvmy996 Is a GOD !
Tim , robs car is making close to that on stock dme i believe .

and joetwint, i think also has the stock unit aswell
 
Old Feb 7, 2011 | 07:55 PM
  #28  
Tim941NYC's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,319
From: Long island NY
Rep Power: 381
Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by MARKSKI@911tuning
We do not have any issues with the blow thru... 1000 rwhp + no problem.... I can see a problem on a stock maf... we actually did a no maf and compared it to the blow thru... such little gains that it was not even worth it... using the blow thru changes the tables sucg that you can actually dial in yout timing and afrs becasue the engine load actually is within range unlike the stock maf maps...
just a thought...
Thank you for your input.
 
Old Feb 7, 2011 | 08:20 PM
  #29  
Tim941NYC's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,319
From: Long island NY
Rep Power: 381
Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !Tim941NYC Is a GOD !
Fmu's to trick small injector is why rods bend and head gaskets get knocked out.

It is easy math. 1200bhp (crank) with 6 cylinders with a brake specific consumption 0.65 with a max duty cycle of 80% with a base fuel psi of 43.5 you will need 6 injectors 163.44 lbs. (1718cc)

you need to burn that much fuel in order to make the btu's to make that hp. Period.

lets go over fuel psi, set your regulator 43.5 and use a 1-1 regulator add 30 psi of boost 43.5x30=73.5 but now you have 30 psi of boost pushing against your 73.5 fuel psi so 30-73.5=43.5 The 1-1 boost reference does not change the size of your injector.
 
Old Feb 7, 2011 | 10:55 PM
  #30  
Powell's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 3,475
From: Friendswood, TX
Rep Power: 385
Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !Powell Is a GOD !
I agree that people rely on other things that aren't the smartest idea to make big power which is why I have 160lb injectors for my new setup. As far as everything else though when it comes to tuning with my setup I let Justin do, he's both a friend and my tuner. His records (in MULTIPLE different car manufactures) over the last 15-20 years lead me to believe I think he knows what he's doing.
 


You have already rated this thread Rating: Thread Rating: 0 votes,  average.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:18 PM.