Snapped Camshaft Adjuster Bolt = Engine & Brake Hydraulics Failure ?
Actually a LOT of bolts - most of the bolts on the engine are one-time-use aluminum security bolts. Including the valve cover bolts. You also need valve cover gasket and spark-plug-well gaskets. Total on parts - even from a discount parts dealer is about $1,500-1,600. I believe you also are going to replace the diamond-washer that keeps the actuator fixed on the end of the camshaft. Having a set of camshaft timing tools also will make the probability of a successful job much higher.
It looks like they charged 8, but because that was more than the SA quoted, they discounted it for me, so I can't tell for sure. The SA quoted $2400-$2600 and it ended up being $2697 after adjustments.
I do see people getting silly quotes from greedy dealerships. I can recommend Porsche of Monmouth, Rt 36, West Long Branch NJ - as not being greedy. Perhaps a list of dealerships that have done the job at a reasonable price would be a good way to repay the dealership for not being greedy.
Yours was done at?
List price on the parts from Sunset Porsche (either the WC-22 kit or priced individually) is just under $1500 based on written quotes from them but their regular discounted price is just under $1200. I know my local dealer has a ~25% markup over MSRP as they're the only player in town and that kind of ripoff puts the prices in the $1800 range for just the parts.
My local dealer (NorCal) gave me the below quote:
$3,585 total for the entire job (part/labor/etc).
"The parts needed are the same as listed in the WC22 service action plus two additional solenoids ($256.06 X 2). We have found that the solenoids can be problematic. We replace them because they are mounted next to the cam actuators."
Parts total - $2078.32
Tax - $176.66
Labor - $1,330
$3,585 total for the entire job (part/labor/etc).
"The parts needed are the same as listed in the WC22 service action plus two additional solenoids ($256.06 X 2). We have found that the solenoids can be problematic. We replace them because they are mounted next to the cam actuators."
Parts total - $2078.32
Tax - $176.66
Labor - $1,330
My local dealer (NorCal) gave me the below quote:
$3,585 total for the entire job (part/labor/etc).
"The parts needed are the same as listed in the WC22 service action plus two additional solenoids ($256.06 X 2). We have found that the solenoids can be problematic. We replace them because they are mounted next to the cam actuators."
Parts total - $2078.32
Tax - $176.66
Labor - $1,330
$3,585 total for the entire job (part/labor/etc).
"The parts needed are the same as listed in the WC22 service action plus two additional solenoids ($256.06 X 2). We have found that the solenoids can be problematic. We replace them because they are mounted next to the cam actuators."
Parts total - $2078.32
Tax - $176.66
Labor - $1,330
So far I haven't heard of anyone having a problem with the solenoids. Zilch. Sounds like an upsell to me. BTW - there may be an input screen on the solenoid that can be cleaned.. I seem to recall hearing something about this. It should only need cleaning if the oil has been neglected.
Goodwill?
So far I haven't heard of anyone having a problem with the solenoids. Zilch. Sounds like an upsell to me. BTW - there may be an input screen on the solenoid that can be cleaned.. I seem to recall hearing something about this. It should only need cleaning if the oil has been neglected.
Not excited about it, although better than most have received. My past year repair list exceeds most others I would have to assume
You did good there..
Another chap and I have been doing a bit of research - and he has gotten the aluminum tamperproof bolts out of one of his old adjusters - but the bolts are not at all a common size or shape. And I know of no availability of them from Porsche.
You might be able to source them from BMW - who used a similar adjuster from the same manufacturer, had the same problems and DID issue a service campaign to replace the bolts.
More info on your suggestion would make this thread more useful.



