991
Sponsored by:
Sponsored by:

Video:Porsche 991 CS v Nissan GT-R at track

Thread Tools
 
Rate Thread
 
Old Apr 8, 2012 | 01:08 AM
  #361  
speed21's Avatar
Banned
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 2,634
Rep Power: 249
speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by yrralis1
I came back to this chart ( there are other track comparisons as well) to point out something .In 2008 as compared to now with the 2012 car has made a huge performance jump .

The 2012/13 car IS an improved GTR
.

The current matchup pits the same car names .. but they are not the same cars .
No question. Car looks much the same inside and outside though....there's one big problem right there for me. You'd only hope it rode and shifted better at low speeds....supposed to on all accounts to date. I dunno.... I still can't get over the throw-outs you'd have to deal with and get through to if anything broke. You've heard the saying you can take the person out of the ......... but you can't take the ......... out of the person?. I don't know if it's a road i'd want to really go down at this stage in my life. I've been trying to work my way toward not having to put up with crap like this. Why don't they have a car for you to test drive? Not very confidence inspiring being told if you want one then buy it sight unseen. It's like your starting off over the barrel. No wonder they wind up poking waivers under your nose to sign.
 

Last edited by speed21; Apr 8, 2012 at 01:10 AM.
Old Apr 8, 2012 | 01:16 AM
  #362  
speed21's Avatar
Banned
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 2,634
Rep Power: 249
speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !speed21 Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by yrralis1
According to the data on this forum and Texas Mile results the Gt1 platform is still the king .

However a stock Turbo S vs a stock 07 Turbo is not even close .. the PDK Turbo S will cream it .
True but a lot of those modded cars are no longer really suitable as daily drivers now. The Turbo S/GTR 2013 are untouched, so should be far more comfortable to use on a regular basis...still super fast and capable.
 
Old Apr 8, 2012 | 02:21 AM
  #363  
yrralis1's Avatar
Registered User
15 Year Member
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 9,108
From: South Florida
Rep Power: 529
yrralis1 Is a GOD !yrralis1 Is a GOD !yrralis1 Is a GOD !yrralis1 Is a GOD !yrralis1 Is a GOD !yrralis1 Is a GOD !yrralis1 Is a GOD !yrralis1 Is a GOD !yrralis1 Is a GOD !yrralis1 Is a GOD !yrralis1 Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by speed21
No question. Car looks much the same inside and outside though....there's one big problem right there for me. You'd only hope it rode and shifted better at low speeds....supposed to on all accounts to date. I dunno.... I still can't get over the throw-outs you'd have to deal with and get through to if anything broke. You've heard the saying you can take the person out of the ......... but you can't take the ......... out of the person?. I don't know if it's a road i'd want to really go down at this stage in my life. I've been trying to work my way toward not having to put up with crap like this. Why don't they have a car for you to test drive? Not very confidence inspiring being told if you want one then buy it sight unseen. It's like your starting off over the barrel. No wonder they wind up poking waivers under your nose to sign.
I happen to agree with you on some of this but not all.

I like the looks of the car . I also feel the interior is quite improved . The black edition looks very nice .

Dealership 1 did not have a car. They were very decent though and encouraged me to come in and order one . Since i never drove one I was hoping to do so.

So --

Dealership 2 did have one --but has lost the sale .

2013 is a long time though and GTR cars aren't going anywhere . There are many other dealerships .

It's not like I am suffering if a car deal doesn't fly .
 
Old Apr 8, 2012 | 06:55 AM
  #364  
M3EvoBR's Avatar
Banned
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 278
From: Florida
Rep Power: 39
M3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud of
I have a GTR and have / had owned several Porsches.
My Opinion. I bought the GTR because I was intrigued about it. It's fast, it's practical, it's cheap performance
It supposed to be a great DD, but is not.... too stiff too heavy
it supposed to be a great weekend track toy (when I don't want to tow or bring the Porsche), it's not ... doesn't work at the track
So for the price I can't justify as in MY Opinion is not great in any of the important things to me, but I still like the car.
If I had more money laying around I would probably keep it, but a nicer daily like a C63 or a ML63, which could tow and still be a nice daily makes more sense to me.

Again, my preferences, my use, my opinion.
 
Old Apr 8, 2012 | 07:50 AM
  #365  
Manifold's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 2,670
Rep Power: 195
Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by M3EvoBR
I have a GTR and have / had owned several Porsches.
My Opinion. I bought the GTR because I was intrigued about it. It's fast, it's practical, it's cheap performance
It supposed to be a great DD, but is not.... too stiff too heavy
it supposed to be a great weekend track toy (when I don't want to tow or bring the Porsche), it's not ... doesn't work at the track
So for the price I can't justify as in MY Opinion is not great in any of the important things to me, but I still like the car.
If I had more money laying around I would probably keep it, but a nicer daily like a C63 or a ML63, which could tow and still be a nice daily makes more sense to me.

Again, my preferences, my use, my opinion.
Interesting. I have a C63, and I feel that the GT-R does just about everything the C63 aims to do, except the GT-R does it better (though the C63 certainly has a more usable back seat). Among cars with a 'sedanish' feel, I don't know of anything that surpasses the GT-R (and actually I'd rank the C63 a bit above the Panamera).

But as a DD, the 911 is still my top pick. I find it plenty comfortable, and of course the performance is great.
 
Old Apr 8, 2012 | 08:09 AM
  #366  
M3EvoBR's Avatar
Banned
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 278
From: Florida
Rep Power: 39
M3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud of
The GT-R is extremely stiff, and is right in between my choices.
I never see myself driving the car anymore. The GT3RS is smoother, and 10 times more engaging to drive. I drove to work and back a few times this week, (90miles round trip) and love every second in the car. if I want something comfy I drive the ML550, so no place for the GT-R anymore.
My wife likes to drive it once in a while, as she can't drive stick (and I'm not teaching )
For me is just straight line fast, and also the tranny on a 2009 is rough on traffic and parking lot speeds.
It just doesn't make sense to me, but it's my personal opinion.

Originally Posted by Manifold
Interesting. I have a C63, and I feel that the GT-R does just about everything the C63 aims to do, except the GT-R does it better (though the C63 certainly has a more usable back seat). Among cars with a 'sedanish' feel, I don't know of anything that surpasses the GT-R (and actually I'd rank the C63 a bit above the Panamera).

But as a DD, the 911 is still my top pick. I find it plenty comfortable, and of course the performance is great.
 
Old Apr 8, 2012 | 08:22 AM
  #367  
M3EvoBR's Avatar
Banned
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 278
From: Florida
Rep Power: 39
M3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud of
trust me I tried a lot of cars out there.

The things that I look in a car Today
For a daily (not order related)
Quality, room, power, luxury, comfortable.

FUN for me means track:
So there is only one car that works for me, and that's a Porsche, everything else you're fooling yourself. Reliable, really fast if driven properly and the best feel of them all (my personal opinion) Of course that there are faster cars at the track, but with the same feel, and that can take the abuse, that's only Porsche. I say that because my home track is Sebring, and Sebring is just brutal to any machine.
The GT-R didn't last 5 laps there, the Lambo didn't last 3, my previous GT2 lasted 25K miles, and sold the car in perfect, I mean perfect condition.

You won't be able to use what a GT-R can do on the streets, so to have fun I would need to bring it to the track, so that's not an option as it's not up to the task without modding the crap out of the car, and that's something I don't do anymore.
For that I would choose a Cup, which is built for it, so at the end of the day, comes down to personal preference and choices.
 
Old Apr 8, 2012 | 08:54 AM
  #368  
Manifold's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 2,670
Rep Power: 195
Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by M3EvoBR
trust me I tried a lot of cars out there.

The things that I look in a car Today
For a daily (not order related)
Quality, room, power, luxury, comfortable.

FUN for me means track:
So there is only one car that works for me, and that's a Porsche, everything else you're fooling yourself. Reliable, really fast if driven properly and the best feel of them all (my personal opinion) Of course that there are faster cars at the track, but with the same feel, and that can take the abuse, that's only Porsche. I say that because my home track is Sebring, and Sebring is just brutal to any machine.
The GT-R didn't last 5 laps there, the Lambo didn't last 3, my previous GT2 lasted 25K miles, and sold the car in perfect, I mean perfect condition.

You won't be able to use what a GT-R can do on the streets, so to have fun I would need to bring it to the track, so that's not an option as it's not up to the task without modding the crap out of the car, and that's something I don't do anymore.
For that I would choose a Cup, which is built for it, so at the end of the day, comes down to personal preference and choices.
This is the most compelling Porsche (specifically 911) endorsement I've seen so far in this thread. I do appreciate the radical madness of the GT-R, but as I noted before, I still prefer the feel of the 911, even if it's slower.

Have you driven the 991?
 
Old Apr 8, 2012 | 09:08 AM
  #369  
thackl's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 278
From: Texas
Rep Power: 32
thackl is a name known to allthackl is a name known to allthackl is a name known to allthackl is a name known to allthackl is a name known to allthackl is a name known to all
It's certainly another thing to consider. Many cars can pull off one fast lap, but will they last 25 without breaking/overheating/etc? I don't track (yet), but is is comforting knowing how over-engineered my 911 is.... esp b/c the nearest shop is over 4hrs away

Originally Posted by M3EvoBR
trust me I tried a lot of cars out there.

The things that I look in a car Today
For a daily (not order related)
Quality, room, power, luxury, comfortable.

FUN for me means track:
So there is only one car that works for me, and that's a Porsche, everything else you're fooling yourself. Reliable, really fast if driven properly and the best feel of them all (my personal opinion) Of course that there are faster cars at the track, but with the same feel, and that can take the abuse, that's only Porsche. I say that because my home track is Sebring, and Sebring is just brutal to any machine.
The GT-R didn't last 5 laps there, the Lambo didn't last 3, my previous GT2 lasted 25K miles, and sold the car in perfect, I mean perfect condition.

You won't be able to use what a GT-R can do on the streets, so to have fun I would need to bring it to the track, so that's not an option as it's not up to the task without modding the crap out of the car, and that's something I don't do anymore.
For that I would choose a Cup, which is built for it, so at the end of the day, comes down to personal preference and choices.
 
Old Apr 8, 2012 | 09:16 AM
  #370  
JmanE55's Avatar
Registered User
15 Year Member
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 1,795
From: Sun Diego
Rep Power: 135
JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by speed21
Like yourself I'm not sure either. As unlikely as it would be I've learned to never say never.

Btw on your modded turbo its a toughy to say whether if it would wind up being used as traction in a stock 2013 drag. Just look at the outcomes of stock turbo S's vs some of the heavily modded turbos. Mainly from the get go tho. It sure is fast out of a dig. There is no doubt the new 2013 is a formidable opponent for the 997tt modded or stock. If you can get over the looks and the other issues it'd be the pick performance wise. Drive it if you can. You never know, it may even ride better than your modded car stock.
My stock 13GTR will DESTROY my modded 997TT from a dig, my 09TT can hang with my friend's modded 08GT2 3-5 races from a dig, 30-120 or 60-120. The LC on the 13GTR is insane and the car is a completely different machine than its predecessors in about every ways.

Originally Posted by yrralis1
I came back to this chart ( there are other track comparisons as well) to point out something .In 2008 as compared to now with the 2012 car has made a huge performance jump .

The 2012/13 car IS an improved GTR .

The current matchup pits the same car names .. but they are not the same cars .
The 12/13 is a different animal Larry, I had a 10 and it's much inferior when compares to the 13. I tend to think of myself as a brand ***** sometime but the 13GTR is that much better hence the big price jump over the previous model. I was recently invited to the 2013 GTR Experience by Nissan at Laguna Seca this weekend but I was unable to attend so my friend took my place. He has a 2010 and I cant wait to hear what he has to say about the 13 model. However, here's the thread on nagtroc.com with actual participants sharing their thoughts on the new machine http://www.nagtroc.org/forums/index..../page__st__480

Im a car enthusiast and Im NOT locked into any particular brands (I've had numerous Mercedes, Lexus & Porsche), yes, the Porsche has a strong racing heritage but Nissan also has some racing experience too (I think, I dont know much about Nissan) but I do enjoy the latest GTR for what it offers. Im open minded and willing to give the competition a try.

Originally Posted by yrralis1
I happen to agree with you on some of this but not all.

I like the looks of the car . I also feel the interior is quite improved . The black edition looks very nice .

Dealership 1 did not have a car. They were very decent though and encouraged me to come in and order one . Since i never drove one I was hoping to do so.

So --

Dealership 2 did have one --but has lost the sale .

2013 is a long time though and GTR cars aren't going anywhere . There are many other dealerships .

It's not like I am suffering if a car deal doesn't fly .
Larry, the BE is nicer than the Premium version, it has better seats, lighter wheels (however I prefer the Premium version wheels) and the CF spoiler is sexy. I thought about trading my 13 in for the 13BE but I missed the boat on the white BE my local dealer had. With the recent 2013 GTR Experience offered by Nissan, I think the 13 model will be harder to get because most of the existing owner will dump their cars to get the latest model. Be patient and you'll find the right dealership Larry.
 
Old Apr 8, 2012 | 09:18 AM
  #371  
Manifold's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 2,670
Rep Power: 195
Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by thackl
It's certainly another thing to consider. Many cars can pull off one fast lap, but will they last 25 without breaking/overheating/etc? I don't track (yet), but is is comforting knowing how over-engineered my 911 is.... esp b/c the nearest shop is over 4hrs away
I can attest that none of the AMGs are really track-ready cars. The weakest link seems to be the transmission. The SLS comes closest to handling this challenge, but even its transmission starts to give when pushed hard for many laps.

I've heard the same comment in other forums that Porsche is the most track-ready car out there (in stock form), at least under $200K. I guess decades of racing experience at the highest level do make a difference!
 
Old Apr 8, 2012 | 09:23 AM
  #372  
M3EvoBR's Avatar
Banned
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 278
From: Florida
Rep Power: 39
M3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud of
Originally Posted by Manifold
This is the most compelling Porsche (specifically 911) endorsement I've seen so far in this thread. I do appreciate the radical madness of the GT-R, but as I noted before, I still prefer the feel of the 911, even if it's slower.

Have you driven the 991?
I rode in it, but I didn't have the chance to drive it yet (time). I was about to go to the dealership yesterday to do so, but never happened.
The more I look at it the more I like it. The interior is superb comparing to the older models, it was a big improvement, but I like the old simple raw look.
The older I get, the more I like the older air cooled, but wouldn't give up on my RS, maybe for a cup, or a stripped track only car.
 
Old Apr 8, 2012 | 09:23 AM
  #373  
Manifold's Avatar
Registered User
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 2,670
Rep Power: 195
Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !Manifold Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by JmanE55
My stock 13GTR will DESTROY my modded 997TT from a dig, my 09TT can hang with my friend's modded 08GT2 3-5 races from a dig, 30-120 or 60-120. The LC on the 13GTR is insane and the car is a completely different machine than its predecessors in about every ways.

The 12/13 is a different animal Larry, I had a 10 and it's much inferior when compares to the 13. I tend to think of myself as a brand ***** sometime but the 13GTR is that much better hence the big price jump over the previous model. I was recently invited to the 2013 GTR Experience by Nissan at Laguna Seca this weekend but I was unable to attend so my friend took my place. He has a 2010 and I cant wait to hear what he has to say about the 13 model. However, here's the thread on nagtroc.com with actual participants sharing their thoughts on the new machine http://www.nagtroc.org/forums/index..../page__st__480

Im a car enthusiast and Im NOT locked into any particular brands (I've had numerous Mercedes, Lexus & Porsche), yes, the Porsche has a strong racing heritage but Nissan also has some racing experience too (I think, I dont know much about Nissan) but I do enjoy the latest GTR for what it offers. Im open minded and willing to give the competition a try.

Larry, the BE is nicer than the Premium version, it has better seats, lighter wheels (however I prefer the Premium version wheels) and the CF spoiler is sexy. I thought about trading my 13 in for the 13BE but I missed the boat on the white BE my local dealer had. With the recent 2013 GTR Experience offered by Nissan, I think the 13 model will be harder to get because most of the existing owner will dump their cars to get the latest model. Be patient and you'll find the right dealership Larry.
Thanks for the info. It does sound like the 2013 has taken the GT-R to a new level. I'd certainly be open to trying one as a possible future car.
 
Old Apr 8, 2012 | 09:34 AM
  #374  
JmanE55's Avatar
Registered User
15 Year Member
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 1,795
From: Sun Diego
Rep Power: 135
JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !JmanE55 Is a GOD !
Originally Posted by Manifold
Thanks for the info. It does sound like the 2013 has taken the GT-R to a new level. I'd certainly be open to trying one as a possible future car.
I would definitely give the GTR at least a test drive, who knows, it might change your mind about the car but be warned, the interior quality isnt anywhere close to your 991. You'll experience noisy suspension/transmission, random cabin noises and the break so squeaks but it can be fixed with the volume button turned up higher than normal level...
 
Old Apr 8, 2012 | 09:39 AM
  #375  
M3EvoBR's Avatar
Banned
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 278
From: Florida
Rep Power: 39
M3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud ofM3EvoBR has much to be proud of
Originally Posted by JmanE55
My stock 13GTR will DESTROY my modded 997TT from a dig, my 09TT can hang with my friend's modded 08GT2 3-5 races from a dig, 30-120 or 60-120. The LC on the 13GTR is insane and the car is a completely different machine than its predecessors in about every ways.



The 12/13 is a different animal Larry, I had a 10 and it's much inferior when compares to the 13. I tend to think of myself as a brand ***** sometime but the 13GTR is that much better hence the big price jump over the previous model. I was recently invited to the 2013 GTR Experience by Nissan at Laguna Seca this weekend but I was unable to attend so my friend took my place. He has a 2010 and I cant wait to hear what he has to say about the 13 model. However, here's the thread on nagtroc.com with actual participants sharing their thoughts on the new machine http://www.nagtroc.org/forums/index..../page__st__480

Im a car enthusiast and Im NOT locked into any particular brands (I've had numerous Mercedes, Lexus & Porsche), yes, the Porsche has a strong racing heritage but Nissan also has some racing experience too (I think, I dont know much about Nissan) but I do enjoy the latest GTR for what it offers. Im open minded and willing to give the competition a try.



Larry, the BE is nicer than the Premium version, it has better seats, lighter wheels (however I prefer the Premium version wheels) and the CF spoiler is sexy. I thought about trading my 13 in for the 13BE but I missed the boat on the white BE my local dealer had. With the recent 2013 GTR Experience offered by Nissan, I think the 13 model will be harder to get because most of the existing owner will dump their cars to get the latest model. Be patient and you'll find the right dealership Larry.
Don't get me wrong, I had/have Mercedes, BMW, Porsche, Lambo, GT-R's everything in between, and in my opinion, for my needs, there was no other car than a Porsche to enjoy what I enjoy.
I heard from a lot of people, why are you not racing ?
Simple, I can't afford to race, and my track time, is my fun time, not work.
We have a very nice group of friends, that drives the same cars, so we have our little time battle and a lot of beer !
There are a lot of manufactures out there with amazing racing heritage, but I think from what I can remember, today Porsche is probably the company that has a race car, that is so close to the street one.
It's manufacture's choice to use it and to provide a car that is so track ready. Im sure a lot more could do but they just choose not to.
 


You have already rated this thread Rating: Thread Rating: 0 votes,  average.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:26 AM.